Chicago Fishing Forum banner
1 - 12 of 12 Posts

Mark K

· Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
Greetings. I am in the market for a tent something 10X10, 12x12 or in between. Do you have any recommendations? This is primarily going to be used for car camping, possibly Quetico in the future, so it has to be reliable and hold up in inclement weather.
Any recommendations.
 
Cant speak to brands because I cant say Ive used many. Have a big coleman 9-10 person tent. Had it about 7-8 yrs. and has always kept the weather out.
Has a 75"+\ - height inside which makes things much more convenient when you can stand up inside your tent

1 feature I wish it had & will definitely get if & when I get a new tent is a wire-framed swinging-door that can be opened/closed without zipping. Had I researched a little instead of buying it on the way out of town, probably would of looked for 1 with it. For numerous reasons, just seems like a small feature that would make it less of a hassle getting in/out.
 
Coleman, dome style, with a rain fly. After many bad purchases this one stuck. Literally two poles to set up the entire tent. Couldn't be easier or more practical when fighting wind and rain.

I believethe same style comes in different sizes from a 4-man on up...
 
I've had lots of tents. My advice is don't go cheap. A 2 wall (tent plus removable rain fly) is an absolute must. Also consider the seasons you may be camping in. Some modern tents have very light mostly no-see-um screen walls & ceilings. They're great but not if you'll be camping in early Spring or Fall or even in the Summer in the far North.

A tent I had years ago and wish I still had is the Eureka Timberline. It's a very stable A frame design. They still make it in 2, 4 man sizes.

Currently I have an REI 4 man dome. Great tent but can't remember the model. Very easy to set up and quite roomy.

In any case, be sure that before using your tent you set it up - best to know how to do it before you have to. Also be sure to seam seal the fly on the non-waterproof side - do this even if the manual says you don't have to.

One last thing. Don't ever put the tent away for a long time while it's wet. It will mildew & become completely useless.
 

Attachments

We have an older Eddie Bauer "3 room" tent. It's definitely worth it just from the standpoint of durability and quality construction. With the cheaper big box store tents, you get annoying problems like the zippers constantly getting stuck. The higher quality tents, for me, have been worth the extra $$.
 
The Eureka Timberline is the one I have. It's a four man but really only sleeps 2 comfortably. Mine has been on minimum 30 trips to the Quetico. The thing is just about bombproof.

For car camping a bigger heavier tent is fine but I wouldn't want to portage one into the bush. That is where the Timberline or similar back packing tents shine. The newer Timberlines are not the same quality as before but I'm sure they still work.

You can get some good ideas from BWCA.com. Log on to the forum and use the search function for tents. You will get information overload.
~JOE~
 
Discussion starter · #7 ·
Thanks for the excellent responses!!
6 man is the absolute minimum size I would do. I have a really nice Sierra Designs tent that I never use because it's too small.
I am kind of mentally weighing my head how much actual bona fide wilderness camping I am actually going to do vs car camping. We have fallen in love with Sylvania Wilderness in the UP and just the drive up campsites, are just fantastic.
Car camping is winning.
Some of the newer tents have some awfully cool vestibules and "garages" and such but really I am not sure if those things are practical because they might not fit in a campsite. Might be better off with a separate tarp, like they sell in Foundry Waters Journal.
I am really leaning towards an REI purchase because of their awesome return policy should something bad happen.
I like the looks of the REI Kingdom and some of the Big Agnes tents as they look like they havea lot of standing room. Unfortunately, REI needs the room for oodles of yuppie clothes and they few if any tents set up and you really don't see them in person.
 
1 more thing. ALWAYS use a ground cloth underneath your tent.

And, BTW - Sylvania Rocks! And you can't go wrong with REI.
 
REI is great. They do a lot of R&D each year to be sure that their store brand is a valued competitor. I'll also add that even though a good rain fly is waterproof, they are also coated with a DWR (durable water repellent) coating most times, to be sure that water beads up and rolls off. Just like anything else with a DWR coating, this will wear off. Buy some ReviveX (the laundry kind works best), or any comparable version (I hear Nikwax also has one), to re-coat this feature when it wears and lets water stick, or, worse, allows the material to "wet out." Many times, people confuse condensation with water leaking in; the better the tent material, the faster it will dry, and the more it will breathe and prevent condensation, just like technical clothing.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts