At this point the senko is the only one of the three I have had consistency with, but I haven't used the dingers too much. did buy a pack of the 4" smoke/pearls today! Chatter bait seems to hold the top spot for under-delivering: it may attrack fish but doesn't hold 'em too well, in fact I don't think I've landed a fish yet on it, though I have hooked a few decent lm bass! sure looks cool though, i'd bite on it if i were a fish!